Is goat milk soap good for your skin? It tends to suit dry and sensitive skin best, and the reason is one substitution: milk where most soap uses water. Here is what that milk does, and whose skin it suits.
Nearly all soap begins the same way. Oils are combined with a lye solution, the two react, and what comes out is soap with a little glycerin alongside it. The liquid that carries the lye is nearly always water, because water is plentiful and brings nothing of its own. In a Firehorse goat's milk bar, milk stands in for that water. The milk we use comes from a small family-run farm in Lucerne Valley, and everything it carries comes into the bar with it.
What the fat does
Milk is mostly water, but the part that is not water is what matters here. Goat's milk carries its fat in small droplets, and that fat joins the oils already in the recipe. Some of it becomes soap. The rest stays as fat, held in the bar until the moment it is worked into a lather on the skin. That is why the lather of a milk bar is dense rather than airy, more cream than foam. It is also why skin is left with a thin softness after rinsing, instead of the tight feeling a water bar can leave.
There is sugar in milk as well, and sugar helps a lather build. This is the part people notice first. A goat's milk bar lathers quickly in the hand, holds that lather while it is used, and rinses away without leaving a film.
Lactic acid and pH
Milk also brings lactic acid, the same acid that gives yogurt its edge. In a bar it works quietly, loosening the dull surface cells that ordinary washing leaves in place. Skin feels smoother for it, without any grit in the bar doing the work. None of this is a treatment. It is what the material does, and it is the reason a milk bar feels different from a plain one in ordinary use.
A bar of true soap is mildly alkaline, which is what lets it lift oil and dirt at all. Skin sits on the slightly acid side. It returns there on its own once the soap is rinsed away, and a milk bar makes that return a short trip by leaving fat behind rather than taking it. The goat's milk lotion is made to sit close to the skin's own pH. It goes on after the bath without asking the skin to adjust a second time.
A hard bar, and whose skin it suits
Our bars are hard, long-lasting bars. A supermarket bar is milled and pressed by machine, often with its glycerin taken out for sale elsewhere. Many are not soap at all, but a detergent shaped like one. A handmade bar keeps its glycerin. Glycerin draws water toward itself, which is good news on the skin and a small responsibility at the sink. Left sitting in a puddle, a bar wears away faster than it should. Left on a dish that drains, it keeps its shape and its lather. There is more on how to make bar soap last longer elsewhere in the Journal.
Who tends to prefer a milk bar is fairly consistent. People with dry skin, people whose skin reacts to what it is given, and anyone who has stepped out of the shower feeling clean but tight. It suits sensitive skin because there is less in it to argue with. The fat it leaves behind does part of the moisturizer's work before the towel comes out.
For skin that also objects to scent, the place to start is the Fragrance Free 100% Goatsmilk Bar, which is the milk and the oils with nothing added for scent. The same milk goes into the Goat's Milk Lotion Unscented, so the two can be used together without introducing anything new. Start there. Add scent later, if the skin allows it.